THE ROLE OF EXPERTISE OF GOODS IN EVALUATION ACTIVITY

Main Article Content

T. LOZOVA
https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4681-5849
N. POPOVYCH
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4407-105X
М. BEDNARCHUK
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-4327-8390

Abstract

Purpose. With the help of the basic structural elements of the internal nature of the product, reveal the objective connection and the role of product examination in evaluation activities.


Methodology. The research uses general scientific analytical methods of obtaining objective data: procedural abstraction; formalization; historical and retrospective review; analysis (systemic, morphological, empirical, structural-logical, systemic) and synthesis; theoretical generalization.


The results. It has been established that in modern conditions, expert and evaluation activities are closely related. It is shown that the determination of the market value of goods today is carried out in a number of areas of activity - expert commoditisation, evaluation, forensic commoditisation, etc. It has been proven that the study of objective obligations in the conditional system "Expertise of goods - Appraisal activities" has general theoretical and practical significance. Through the prism of the internal connections of expert and evaluation activities, an analysis of the content of the main current legal acts that regulate evaluation activities in Ukraine, fundamental scientific developments in this area, and relevant literary sources on commodity science and commodity expertise was carried out. It has been proven that from the standpoint of evaluation activities, goods that are the object of commodity science and the object of commodity expertise can be considered as movable property, which, as an object of commodity science, falls under the main categories of classification, in particular, has signs of classification and is object of commodity classification. The results of the analysis of the internal nature of the goods of  individual consumption chosen for the study proved that the subject of the commodity examination of goods, the object of which is, in particular, consumer goods, and the evaluation activity, the object of which is, in particular, property, are the signs of the classification of these goods, which at the appropriate level of product research are factors in the formation of their market value. On the basis of the above, a scheme of the relationship between goods examination and evaluation activities has been developed, which clearly illustrates that the nomenclature of factors of market value formation formed by an expert based on the scientific classification of goods is a scientifically based guarantee, on the one hand, of the objectivity of the results of commodity examination in the process of establishing of the market value of goods in forensic expert activity, and on the other hand - objective evaluation of goods in the process of evaluation activity.


The scientific novelty of the obtained results lies in the development of the scientific foundations of goods examination due to the use of knowledge about the internal nature of goods for the needs of evaluation activities.


The practical significance of the obtained research results lies in the improvement of the process of commodity studies and assessment activities in terms of the scientific substantiation of objects and comparison criteria, as well as in their possible use in the training of commodity science students in higher education institutions and in improving the qualifications of commodity science experts.

Article Details

How to Cite
LOZOVA, T., POPOVYCH , N., & BEDNARCHUKМ. (2023). THE ROLE OF EXPERTISE OF GOODS IN EVALUATION ACTIVITY. Tovaroznavchiy Visnik, 1(16), 141-150. https://doi.org/10.36910/6775-2310-5283-2023-17-12
Section
ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND TRADE
Author Biographies

T. LOZOVA, Lviv University of Trade and Economics

doctor of technical sciences, professor, professor of the department of commodity science, customs affairs and quality management of the Lviv trade and economic department university

N. POPOVYCH , Lviv University of Trade and Economics National University «Lviv Polytechnic»

candidate of technical sciences, associate professor, associate professor of the department of commodity science, customs affairs and quality management of the Lviv trade and economic department university

М. BEDNARCHUK, Lviv Research Forensic Centre of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine

candidate of technical sciences, professor, head of the monitoring and information support sector of the Lviv Research Expert Forensic Center of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Ukraine

References

1. Aktualni pytannia ekspertnoi ta otsinochnoi diialnosti : materialy I Mizhnarodnoi naukovo-praktychnoi konferentsii (Starobilsk-Poltava, 27-28 lystopada 2019 roku). Poltava : Poltaskyi universytet ekonomiky i torhivli, 2019. 440 s.
2. Pro sudovu ekspertyzu : Zakon Ukrainy 25.02.1994 (Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy), 1994, № 28, st. 232.
3. Pro otsinku maina, mainovykh prav ta profesiinu otsinochnu diialnist v Ukraini : Zakon Ukrainy 12.01.2001 № 2658 (Vidomosti Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy), 2001, № 47, st. 25.
4. Pro zatverdzhennia Natsionalnoho standartu N 1 «Zahalni zasady otsinky maina i mainovykh prav»: Postanova Kabinetu Ministriv Ukrainy vid 10.09.2003 r. № 1440. Dokument 1440-2003-p, potochna redaktsiia – vid 15.04.2015. URL: https://zakon2.rada. gov.ua/laws/ show/1440-2003-%D0%BF (data zvernennia: 10.01.2023).
5. Otsinka maina i mainovykh prav v Ukraini / za red. N. Lebid. Kyiv : Informatsiino- vydavnycha firma "Print-Ekspres", 2007. 688 s.
6. Teoriia ta praktyka provedennia sudovykh ekspertyz za napriamkom inzhenernykh, ekonomichnykh, tovaroznavchykh vydiv doslidzhen ta otsinochnoi diialnosti / za red. V. P. Khomutenko, O. Yu. Kostina. Odesa : FOP Huliaieva V. M., 2018. 274 s.
7. Otsinochna diialnist u sviti : porivnialnyi analiz. Pan-Ukrainian Association of Valuation Specialists (PUAVS): veb sait. URL: http://www.afo.com.ua/uk/news/2/1140 (data zvernennia 10.01.2023).
8. Vozna M. Mizhnarodni standarty otsinky: pryntsypy, standarty ta pravyla / za redaktsiieiu O. Drapiovskoho, I. Ivanovoi ; pereklad z anhliiskoi. Kyiv : UKRels, 1999. 118 s.
9. Alico, J. Editor Appraising Machinery and Equipment. McGraw-Hill book Compani;
1989.
10. Zayats, R. Development of the general criteria of assessment of the demolition of
the light industry during in the forensi examination. International scientific-practical conference of judicial experts «Contemporary approaches when performing judicial expertise: theory and practice» (01 october 2021, Chisinau). Volumul II. Р. 214-222.
11. Metodyka provedennia tovaroznavchoi ekspertyzy ekspertamy torhovo- promyslovykh palat v Ukraini. Kyiv : Torhovo-promyslova palata Ukrainy, 2005. 48 s.
12. Kolomiiets T. M., Prytulska N. V., Romanenko O. L. Ekspertyza tovariv. Kyiv : Kyivskyi natsionalnyi torhovelno-ekonomichnyi universytet. 2001. 274 s.
13. Batutina A. P., Yemchenko I. B. Ekspertyza tovariv. Kyiv: Tsentr uchbovoi literatury, 2003. 275 s.
14. Kozmych D. I., Kobyshchan A. D., Nazarenko L. O. Ekspertyza tovariv. Poltava : Poltavskyi universytet ekonomiky i torhivli, 2011. 374 s.
15. DSTU 3993-2000. Tovaroznavstvo. Terminy ta vyznachennia. [Chynnyi vid 2001- 01-01]. Vydannia ofitsiine. Kyiv : Derzhstandart Ukrainy, 2000. 24 s.
16. Zhuk Yu. T., Zhuk V. A., Kysliak N. K., Kushnir M. K. [ta in.]. Teoretychni osnovy tovaroznavstva. Kyiv: NMTs "Ukooposvita", 2000. 336 s.
17. Artiukh T.M. Teoretychni osnovy tovaroznavstva. Navchalnyi posibnyk /T.M. Artiukh, I.V. Hryhorenko. Kyiv: NUKhT, 2017. 296 s.
18. Bednarchuk M. S. Problemy klasyfikatsii tekstylnykh materialiv dlia odiahu i vzuttia. Lviv: Kooposvita LKA, 2000. 36 s.
19. Syrokhman I. V., Zadorozhnyi I. M., Ponomarov P. Kh. Tovaroznavstvo prodovolchykh tovariv. Kyiv : Libra, 1997. 632 s.
20. Kushnir M. K., Tykhonova N. P. Tovaroznavstvo neprodovolchykh tovariv. Ch. III. Kyiv : Navchalno-metodychnyi tsentr «Ukooposvita», 2001. 266 s.
21. DSTU 4135-2021. Tsukerky. Zahalni tekhnichni umovy. [Chynnyi vid 2021-10-01]. Vydannia ofitsiine. Kyiv: DP «UkrNDNTs», 2021. 21 s.
22. DSTU 2157-93 Vzuttia. Terminy ta vyznachennia. [Chynnyi vid 1994-01-01]. Vydannia ofitsiine. Kyiv: Derzhstandart Ukrainy, 1994. 67 s.